Remove a countable set of points from an open set

Let A be an open set. Show that if a finite number of points are removed from A, the remaining set is still open. Is the same true if a countable number of points are removed?


If we order the points removed from A, x1 < x2 < … < xk we can write A − {x1, x2, …, xk} = A ∩ ((−∞, x1) ∪ (x1, x2) ∪ (x2, x3) ∪ …(xk−1, xk) ∪ (xk, ∞)) B := (−∞, x1) ∪ (x1, x2) ∪ (x2, x3) ∪ …(xk−1, xk) ∪ (xk, ∞) is a union of open sets, hence open. A ∩ B is a finite intersection of open sets, hence it is also open.

The statement is not true for countable number of points. Consider R − Q. This is not open, since given any irrational point x, by the density of rational, we can find for every n a rational y ∈ (x − 1/n, x + 1/n), hence we couldn’t find a neighborhood around x completely in R − Q .

Cloud Advisory Services | Security Advisory Services | Data Science Advisory and Research

Specializing in high volume web and cloud application architecture, Anuj Varma’s customer base includes Fortune 100 companies (, British Petroleum, Schlumberger).

All content on this site is original and owned by AdverSite Web Holdings, Inc. – the parent company of No part of it may be reproduced without EXPLICIT consent from the owner of the content.

Anuj Varma – who has written posts on Anuj Varma, Technology Architect.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *